Our Story

Our story at Cardinal Pizza was created in 2019 out of a passion for amazing food and service. Through word of mouth, a commitment to producing the freshest pizza and a lot of hard work, Cardinal Pizza has rapidly become the most beloved restaurant in Westerville’s uptown district.

Cardinal Pizza opened with a completely redesigned space and a menu that harkens back to the original landmark we are housed in – featuring mouthwatering New York and Columbus style pizza, full bar, draft beer, and the largest craft beer selection in Westerville. All available for timely delivery.

Catering
Our excellence has been honed by long days in front of blazing ovens engaged in culinary exploration, then crafted to match your imagination. Cardinal Pizza’s owners have over 30 combined years of experience managing such venues as country clubs, resorts, banquet halls, and restaurants.

We believe that using the freshest ingredients produces the tastiest results. This means using local products whenever we can. We are focused on creating customized menus and meal-time masterpieces for our catering partners. Whether it’s a pizza party, an office lunch, or a banquet, we’re confident we will make your vision a reality.

Mission
We will strive to provide the tastiest link between regional producers and our guests.

Community Involvement
We give charitably to our community partners and schools. Cardinal Pizza gives to Whittier Elementary School, sponsors Rotary Fourth of July, enables fundraising to such organizations as W.A.R.M., and Nationwide Slice of Columbus.